Perdido 03

Perdido 03

Sunday, June 8, 2014

The "Unintended Consequences" Of The Common Core And The Education Reform Movement

An editorial from the New Hampshire Union Leader:

Kids and cursive Common Core fallout

Unintended consequences are beginning to sprout in the wake of U.S. education decisions.

For one thing, there is the move to do away with any concentration on handwriting other than in kindergarten and first grade. For another, there is the federal overreach on common standards.
A lengthy New York Times report last week on research done elsewhere says that a lot more than the ability to write in cursive is at stake regarding the scrapping of handwriting. Several studies have shown that handwriting engages portions of the brain that a keyboard does not.
"When we write, a unique neural circuit is automatically activated," said a French psychologist. "There is a core recognition of the gesture in the written word, a sort of recognition by mental stimulation in your brain. And it seems that this circuit is contributing in unique ways we didn't realize."
"Learning," said Stanislas Dehaene, "is made easier."

"When learning to write by hand," the Times noted, "children better generate ideas and retain information."

Who would have thunk it?

Don't think the fuss over "Common Core" standards is any big deal? It happens that those standards include ending the teaching of handwriting after the first grade.
Incidentally, Oklahoma Gov. Mary Fallin signed legislation last week that ends that state's adherence to Common Core.

"It has become very apparent to me that the word Common Core has become a word that is tainted, that is divisive, that has caused widespread concern throughout our state," Fallin said.

According to the Oklahoman newspaper, the standards "were developed in a state-led effort launched in 2009 through the National Governors Association, a group Fallin now heads. Meant to be rigorous and advance critical thinking, they were adopted voluntarily by 45 states and the District of Columbia. Oklahoma joins Indiana in repealing them."

Fallin faulted the Obama administration for using federal funds as either cudgel or reward on the issue, noting that Washington offers financial "incentives'' for those states that, like New Hampshire, go along with the standards.

Perhaps our own state board, which claims no local district need adopt the standards but is making it impossible to avoid them, can try this assignment: Write 100 times, in longhand, New Hampshire can do better than Common Core.

My 11th graders told me this year that they can't seem to write without a rubric and an outline anymore, two items that the Common Core and the Danielson teacher evaluation rubric as practiced in my school specialize in festishizing.

When I asked students to write a personal piece about a struggle they have had and what they have learned from that struggle (a piece that could take the form of either a personal essay, a narrative or poetry), many students said they had difficulty starting because they hadn't written anything creative all year and weren't really reading much in the way of literature or poetry anymore (this is much worse for 9th graders, where they are getting the education malfeasance that is the EngageNY curriculum, but it's still bad at all levels in high school.)

We have been told by the self-described geniuses who brought us the Common Core, the Danielson framework and the other ancillary reforms that go with these that the proof will be there after a decade of reform, that students will be going to college and showing up in their careers ready to do the "rigorous" work the 21st Century workplace will require.

But the consequences from these reforms are showing up already - especially the damage the Common Core and the Endless Testing that goes with it is doing to the emotional health of children.

The Union Leader says these consequences are unintended, but I'm not so sure.

In a country where the economic and social elite seem to want to own 100% of the country, you can see the value in an education revolution that dumbs down most of the populace and does severe emotional and psychological harm to them.

In any case, whether the consequences are unintended, as the Union Leader says they are, or they're intended, as I tend to think they are, the consequences to the reform agenda are showing up already.

The Common Core Generation is going to be a Lost Generation.


  1. If your 11th and 9th graders are responding this way, imagine how those who have known only common core and danielson are affected.
    Just as with TC, where "turn and talk" became the robotic command giving little ones permission to speak only when allowed, common core and danielson keep you inside the box. The box of mediocrity for the masses. Dumb us down so that we may do your bidding. We have entered the new dark ages.

    1. Michael FiorilloJune 9, 2014 at 4:17 AM

      yes, as lewis Mumford predicted over half a century ago: The Electronic Dark Ages...