On Thursday, he got beaten up pretty badly at a state PTA-sponsored town hall meeting on the Common Core in Poughkeepsie, as parents attacked him over his education reform agenda, problems with the Common Core standards, the inBloom data project and King's hypocrisy for sending his own kids to Montessori Unlimited, a private school with the motto "We believe education should be about more than memorization, repetition and standardized tests," while he forces memorization, repetition and standardized tests on the rest of the children in the state.
But CNY Teacher posts that King did another Common Core p.r. meeting on Monday in Whiteboro that did not go so well either (though it didn't quite approach the meltdown moments King experienced on Thursday):
You can see the anger parents have over the Common Core reforms King is pushing and, just as King didn't seem to win over anybody to his agenda on Thursday, he doen't seem to win over anybody on Monday night either.
Now of course King won't be winning anybody over to his agenda, because he's canceled all of the remaining PTA-sponsored meetings with parents (though there may be an October 15 meeting that is not sponsored by the state PTA that he is still scheduled to attend - well see if he makes that date.)
CNY Teacher wonders if King hasn't become a liability to the deform movement at this point, the face of policy intractability and public official intransigence:
After the epic public relations failure that unfolded in Whiteboro and Spackenkill this week, is it possible that the politicians and bureaucrats in Albany will come to view Commissioner King as a political liability? Has his ability to effectively manage the state’s reform agenda been so compromised that Board of Regents Chancellor Tisch, Governor Cuomo, and NYSUT President Ianuzzi will finally call for King’s resignation?
It's clear from the commentary across Twitter and the blogosphere this weekend that Commissioner King is now a target of derision, mockery and ridicule.
Ed Notes Online found him in the witness protection program, B-Lo-Ed Scene noted how King can't handle any crowd that doesn't respond with adoration for his reforminess, NYC Educator found that King can only dish out the abuse but can't handle it, NYC School Parents blog posted that King's cancellations of the future PTA-sponsored events with parents only reinforces the meme that SED officials are out of touch and incommunicado with parents, and here at Perdido Street School blog we found Commissioner King rated "ineffective" on the Danielson rubric for effective commissioners, although when King decided to cancel the rest of the remaining PTA p.r. dates, he did inexplicably make a pineapple and hare very happy and we were able to award him a Profile in Cowardice certificate.
I posted yesterday that if King were an astute politician, he would cancel the cancellations of the PTA-sponsored town halls and go out and meet the people, take his beatings over Common Core with grace and good humor, pay lip service to parents' concerns and then continue to do what he's doing on policy without any change of course.
I don't think that tactic would end the criticism of SED and the Regents, nor do I think it would save the Common Core State (sic) Standards and SED testing regime from their ultimate demise (not with the state having made parents in affluent areas like Scarsdale, Great Neck, Garden City and the like upset over the agenda.)
But I do think such a strategy would save King from being seen as a political liability by the deformers in power in Albany and NYC, something that is almost certain to happen if parents continue to rise up in anger and fury all over the state and King goes into hiding in Albany and lets his SED deputies deal with the furor (as he did on Long Island back in September.)
If King doesn't have the courage to face critics and defend himself and his education deform agenda from detractors, then he doesn't much serve the powers that be looking to promote the corporate deform agenda any longer and they will turn on him the way they would turn on any of their own ilk who no longer serve their interests.
UPDATE - 11:40 AM: The October 15 town hall has been canceled.
Commissioner King has gone from the Ed Deformer Boy Wonder to the Wizard of Oz, a charlatan hiding behind the curtains at SED.
Citizens of New York, arise and sign the petition to terminate John King.
ReplyDeletehttp://www.change.org/petitions/new-york-state-board-of-regents-terminate-the-employment-of-state-education-commissioner-john-king
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteWhat's REALLY obvious now is John King has no respect from anyone. When you become a target of ridicule, derision and scorn there is no coming back. I have been watching the Bad Ass Teachers New York page on Facebook pretty closely and it's clear this guy is now little more than a buffoon and a laughingstock. His situation is terminal and there is nothing for him to do now but step aside. You are a step ahead of a lot of us I think in recognizing that his own team has to be looking at him the same way, the way we as teachers look at a terrible teacher who is flaming out and bringing us down. Warm up the Prius Johnny, this party is OVER.
DeleteHe's made things even worse by blaming "special interests" in his statement explaining the town hall cancellations. Calling parents "special interests" is not the smartest crisis management move he could make here.
DeleteYes, indeed.
DeleteHe really sank himself with this line; keep it up John and you'll head into the Cathy Black unpopularity zone. It was not a teachers union group but parents that were vocal at this meeting.
By blaming "special interests" he could only be referring to parents. In this case it was fortunate that the union was absent. With that target missing it was clear that he was attacking parents.
NO CUOMO IN 2014. Where is the progressive challenger? There are 12 months to go. Sure, there will be millions of corporate Gate$ and Pear$on dollars showered on Cuomo.
But the people will be on the other side, opposite Cuomo.
ICE's blog has a link to a Buffalo News report on a 2 thousand strong protest forum backed by some anti-test madness pols mentioned:
http://www.buffalonews.com/city-region/education/forum-on-testing-reform-draws-2500-vocal-teachers-parents-and-administrators-20131002
So far, there is no progressive challenger. To be honest, I don't think we're going to get one. But Cuomo's got problems stemming from the Moreland mess, and if we can expands those problems by tying him to King/Core, we may be able to hurt him bad enough in 2014 that 2016 because questionable. Although part of me really does want to see him run for president because I want him to get some serious scrutiny that he so far has avoided.
DeleteJohn King is not respected by anyoned because he is intellectually shallow, dishonest and arrogant.
ReplyDeleteHe is all of those. And the arrogance trumps everything else.
DeleteI don't want him to resign. I want him to keep up the work he is doing until Common Core is dead.
ReplyDeleteI am with you on that. I wanted Cathie Black to stay too. Nothing bad happened while Black ran the DOE. When Walcott took over, the aggressive deformer attacks on the system started again.
Delete